The father of my sons was not Christian (he passed away last year). After my sons were born he agreed that I can raise them as Catholics. So they got baptized and were confirmed, we went to holy mass and learned more and more about our faith. As years passed by he disliked it more and more that my children and I lived our faith.
It all looks nice and easy in the beginning, but later the problems will come.
Experience has tought me and I would never choose a non Catholic to marry, if I want to life my faith.
Think about all the very good advices from this thread and don't get taken away by feelings. Life is more than that.