All this well-spirited debate over various forms of the Mass and how one is more valid than the other, and the arguments for all. When did Jesus himself state that all of this is necessary?
Carl, so far people have talked about their personal reactions or preferences to the two major forms of the Mass in the Latin rite. Some, like yourself have mentioned how some people have talked to them about one or the other being more valid. But no one here has said that they believe one was more valid than the other.
In fact, the consensus here is that anyone making a claim that one is more valid or better than the other is off base and should be ignored.