I have found that though there are many guys out there who I would be more than willing to talk to and see where God leads us, there seems to be a feeling of "all or none" amongst our generation. If one doesn't meet all the criteria they are dismissed. Call me crazy, but if we were all meeting in a room full of people instead of online, wouldn't we still be willing to talk to each other and get to know the people in the room, even if it was only a few of them? I am perfectly willing to talk to anybody who talks to me. If things become strange, or uncomfortable then that is the time to take action. Besides, we may not meet the person we are meant for on this site, but perhaps by making friends through this site we are opening up another possibilty for meeting more people. (Who knows what kind of friends/siblings you may meet through someone here.)
I guess my bottom line is, don't dismiss someone if everything is perfect. There are a few things I draw the line at for my future husband, but I would never not reply to someone if those things were not perfect on their profile.