Beth Nudged Mark and He Opened His Heart

Dan Flaherty
Dan Flaherty

Success Stories

January 9th, 2013

Beth Nudged Mark and He Opened His Heart

Beth and Mark were maintaining a consistent email exchange on CatholicMatch, but it was staying on the same level. “Mark’s answers were direct, answers to questions and sharing little,” Beth told CatholicMatch. She decided to take a chance and wrote “a teasing, playful flirt.”

The flirt caused her to immediately second-guess and she feared she had overstepped the boundaries in their correspondence. A letter of apology followed. That was the trigger that opened Mark up.

“Oh Beth,” were the 64-year-old man from Michigan’s first words. “Those two words of reassurance leaped off the page,” Beth fondly recalled. “A clear testament that I found someone with a caring heart.” Mark and Beth were on their way to something special.

Once Mark opened up, he showered Beth with love and affection

Once Mark opened up, he showered Beth with love and affection

Beth had been widowed for three years when she came to CatholicMatch and the 68-year-old who also hailed from Michigan wasn’t sure what to expect from online dating. She saw the CatholicMatch ad in her parish bulletin and figured that her small town—a community of little more than a thousand that she affectionately termed “Podunk USA”—offered little in the way of dating opportunities, so she needed to try something else.

Mark became that “something else” and after their correspondence broke through the initial barrier, they began to date. He took her for a ride on his Harley and out to lunch. During lunch, the shyness that marked his correspondence was gone—he opened up and began talking about himself in-depth. “He later told me he had gone into such depth so I would know he was not a serial killer,” Beth said.

Indeed, Mark was anything but—he was a devoted grandfather who loved to ride his Harley and enjoyed the simple things in life, making him an ideal lifestyle match for a woman who had 40 acres of land, three teenage foster sons and wanted a soulmate to help her care for it all.

Mark embraced the whole of Beth's life, from her three sons to her forty acres.

Mark embraced all of Beth's life, from her three sons to her 40 acres.

After that initial lunch date, Beth had a strong sense that Mark was the one for her. He was always looking out for her, from finding ways to amuse her boys, listening to her closely, helping with the chores and even sending her a rose every week.

It became very apparent to Beth that Mark was in love with her and she reciprocated the feeling. When he would make remarks to her about getting married, she told him “be sure you want to ask that question, because the next time I may answer.” Undeterred, he asked again, there being no doubt he meant what he was asking. And she said yes.

Mark and Beth were married in October and over the past two months, the same affection he showed in courtship remains evident. Both are retired, so they can devote themselves to the boys, to the land and to each other. “Podunk USA” has one new resident and a very happy one at that.

— This article has been read 1,631 times

Find Your Forever

CatholicMatch is the largest and most trusted
Catholic dating site in the world.

Get Started for Free!

Continue Reading

St. Raphael, patron of Catholic singles - Pray for us!

St. Raphael, patron of Catholic singles - Pray for us!

CatholicMatch, Emotigram, Find Your Forever, Grow in Faith - Fall in Love, and Faith Focused Dating are registered trademarks and/or trademarks of CatholicMatch, LLC

© Copyright 2026